WHY GOOD STROKES DON'T WIN MATCHES (And What Does)

By Paul Dale -The 3AM Method

There's a particularly frustrating experience that every competitive tennis player knows too well: you step on court, your strokes are crisp, your footwork feels light, you're striking the ball cleanly—and yet, somehow, you lose. You walk off the court shaking your head, wondering how your "A-game" wasn't enough.

The truth: playing your best tennis doesn't guarantee you'll win matches. Far from it.

The Stroke Quality Trap

We've all been there. Your forehand is painting lines. Your serve has that satisfying pop. Your backhand is flowing effortlessly. By every technical measure, you're playing well. So why is the scoreboard telling a different story?
Because tennis isn't just a stroke production contest—it's a problem-solving battle.
That opponent across the net? They don't care how beautiful your forehand looks. They're not awarding style points for your textbook technique. They're trying to win, and if you're relying solely on the quality of your strokes to get the job done, you're bringing a knife to a strategic gunfight.

Strokes Alone Won't Unlock Skilled Opponents. Here's what separates recreational tennis from competitive tennis: skilled opponents don't beat themselves.

They won't give you easy errors. They won't let you dictate with simple patterns. They'll find your weaknesses, exploit your predictability, and neutralise your weapons. Your best forehand becomes irrelevant if they never give you a chance to hit it. Your powerful serve loses its impact if they step in and take it early.

Against competent players, strokes are merely your tools—but strategy is your blueprint.

The time has come for coaching to embrace every element involved in match-play, including Strategy

The Missing Ingredient: Tactical Intelligence

Think about the players who frustrate you the most. Chances are, they're not the ones with the biggest weapons or the prettiest strokes. They're the ones who:

• Disrupt your rhythm with varied pace, spin, and depth

• Expose your patterns by recognising what you do in certain situations

• Force you into uncomfortable positions rather than letting you set up shop

• Adapt mid-match when their initial game plan isn't working

• Target your weaknesses relentlessly, even when your strengths are on display

These players understand something crucial: tennis is chess at 80 mph. Every shot is a move. Every pattern is a setup. Every point is a puzzle to solve.

Players must be taught to think throughout the match and to search for the correct strategy against each individual opponent

Strategy Over Strokes: What This Actually Means

What does "strategy" look like in practice? It's not some abstract concept—it's concrete decision-making:

Instead of: Hitting your best shot whenever possible
Try: Hitting the shot that creates the best opportunity for the next shot

Instead of playing the same patterns that work in practice
Try: Observing what makes this specific opponent uncomfortable

Instead of: Overpowering with pace
Try: Constructing points with purpose—heavy topspin to pin them back, slice to bring them forward, angles to open the court

Instead of: Serving to your favourite spot
Try: Serving to their weaker return or mixing patterns to keep them guessing

Instead of: Staying in your comfort zone
Try: Making tactical adjustments when you're losing—even if it means temporarily abandoning your "best" shots

The Winning Mindset Shift

The players who win despite not having the "best" strokes share a common trait: they're excellent at identifying and exploiting what the match requires.
They ask themselves:

• What's working against this player right now?

• Where are they vulnerable?

• How can I break their rhythm?

• What adjustments have they made, and how do I counter?

Meanwhile, the player with beautiful strokes but no strategic awareness keeps hitting the same shots, wondering why quality isn't translating to results.

Your Best Tennis Isn't Just About You

Players must adopt an attitude of observing their opponent and adapting to what they discover

Here's the final piece of the puzzle: your "best tennis" shouldn't be defined by how well you execute in isolation. It should be defined by how effectively you solve the specific problem at hand.

Playing your best tennis means:

• Reading the opponent correctly

• Adjusting your tactics based on what's happening

• Being willing to play "ugly" if that's what wins

• Thinking two or three shots ahead

• Staying flexible when your initial plan isn't working

Some days, your best tennis might mean moonballing a big hitter into submission. Other days, it's taking time away from a defensive grinder. Your strokes might feel less pure, but if you're solving the puzzle—if you're finding a way to win—that's playing your best tennis.

The Path Forward

If you've been frustrated by losses despite "playing well," it's time to expand your definition of playing well.

• Start studying your opponents, not just your own technique

• Develop a strategic toolkit, not just a stroke toolkit

• Practice patterns and point construction, not just groundstrokes

• Learn to think tactically under pressure

• Embrace the mental chess match

Tennis is beautiful because it rewards the complete player. Your strokes are important—they're the foundation. But strategy is what builds the house. And in competitive tennis, the player with the best game plan usually outlasts the player with the best groundstrokes.

So the next time you play great tennis but still lose, don't just work harder on your technique. Work smarter on your tactics. Because in tennis, like in chess, the player who thinks better usually wins—even when the other player hits better. 

---